Jane ([info]thirdjane) wrote in [info]trashy_eats,
  • Mood: jubilant
  • Music: Ronnie Milsap- "Back on my Mind Again"

Vicki's Chicken Pot Pie

What follows is the recipe for The Best Chicken Pot Pie You Will Ever Eat. Ever.


You will need:

The Hardware
1 deep casserole dish. (Mine is a glass oval one I've stolen from my mother and I couldn't live without it.) It must be very deep!
2 good-sized bowls.
1 skillet (optional)
a whisk, a rubber spatula, and some other utensils along those lines.
a 1-cup measure and a 1/3-cup measure.
An oven
A stove (optional)


The Edibles
1 can Veg-All mixed vegetables and 1 can of your choice of vegetable (I like green beans) or 2 cans Veg-All mixed vegetables
1 can chicken stock or broth
1 can of condensed cream of chicken soup
1 can of condensed cream of celery soup (So that's what they're used for!)
Some boneless chicken parts (I use breasts, but I've been known to use thighs)
Flour
Milk
Mayonaise (If you don't like it, too bad. Go buy a small jar. Don't use miracle whip. It's called Helmans, it's called BestFoods. Love it. Seriously.)


The Work
Preheat your oven to 350 degrees, as if there was any other temperature one can cook at.
If you would like, sear your chicken to golden brown or poach it, or dye it orange. It doesn't matter. Once you're done, chop it up into good-sized pieces that can fit nicely on a fork. Coat the bottom of your casserole with the chicken. Get a good layer, because it'll shrink a bit. If it looks like you have too much chicken, you have just enough.

Open your cans of vegetables and drain off the liquid. Spread them on top of the chicken. Do NOT mix the chicken and the vegetables! The key to making this all work is LAYERS.

Dump your two soups into a bowl (mmm... ploppy...). Whisk together. Add about half a can of chicken stock. Make it all nice and smooth and creamy. You don't want it too liquidy. It needs to flow but but be watery. Pour soups evenly over chicken and vegetables. Trust me, it's going to be good.

Measure about a cup of flour into your clean bowl. Add 1/3 cup of mayonaise. Don't Complain. Add one cup of milk. Stir till mostly smooth. If there are some lumps, it's okay. Nothing to get too worked over. You're going to need enough batter to pour over the rest of your pie, so if it looks like you won't have enough add more flour, milk, and mayo in the same ratios till it looks like enough.

Pour slowly all over.

Do Not Mix the Soup With The Batter!

If you can, cover all the soup, going all the way to the edge of the casserole dish. Do not allow holes. If there is a small hole you should be able to gently pull batter over it, but be very careful. If you do get a hole it will taste just as good, but it won't look picture perfect.

Gently ease into your oven. Place a cookie sheet or jelly roll pan beneath the pot pie.

Let it go for anywhere from 45 minutes to an hour. Go read a book. Watch some cartoons. Write a reply telling me how wonderful I am. The chicken pot pie will be done when the top is golden brown and yummy yummy good. Trust me, you'll know.

The Enjoyment
Scoop out big portions into bowls and enjoy. Love Southern women and mayonaise in things you never thought.




(Vicki, as you may tell, happens to be my favorite Southern Woman. My best friend is marrying her only son, and whenever I see her we spend hours swapping recipes. She repeatedly surprises me by putting mayonaise in everything I think it should never go in. This is my favorite, but mashed potatoes come a close second... even if I don't do it myself. I recieved this reciepe in exchange for my mother's apple cake. I have yet to find one that earns me her biscuit recipe, which proves how very good they are.)


x-posted like crazy tasty!
Tags: casseroles, main dishes

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Comments allowed for members only

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 11 comments

[info]noo_kitty_kitty

February 18 2005, 16:45:59 UTC 7 years ago

My boyfriend looooooves chicken pot pie, but he only gets it when we go out because I'm afraid of making it. I think I might be able to handle this recipe - when he comes home next month maybe I'll give it a shot!

[info]thirdjane

February 18 2005, 16:49:22 UTC 7 years ago

He will love it!

The first couple times you make it there's a good chance it'll look a bit messy. There will probably be holes in the crust, but don't worry! It took me about three times making it to make it look good.

Even if holes pop up in the crust and it leaks it tastes fantastic

[info]noo_kitty_kitty

February 18 2005, 16:52:43 UTC 7 years ago

He loves the one at cracker barrel, apparently. Have you had that one - does it compare?

Hell, I'm sure since the recipe comes from a southern lady it should be fine!

[info]thirdjane

February 18 2005, 17:07:52 UTC 7 years ago

I don't recall off the top of my head what the CrackBar's pot pie is like, but I need to be calling my friend later, so I will find out. (She works at Cracker Barrel, along with Vicki's son- who she's marrying!)

If they can't say how it compares, I'll be sure to take some pictures of the snowfall in hell.

[info]noo_kitty_kitty

February 18 2005, 17:10:54 UTC 7 years ago

hahaha.. awesome! Thanks~

[info]luxlis

February 18 2005, 17:15:06 UTC 7 years ago

That sounds fabulous!

I always liked the idea of Veg-All. It sounds like it should be a futuristic meal pill. You would take it and have all of your servings of vegetables for the week.

I'm adding this to my memories.

[info]thirdjane

February 18 2005, 18:25:01 UTC 7 years ago

I'm a memory! *dances*

Veg-All = best stuff on earth (after canned peas, because nothing rocks more than a can of peas)

[info]jbmanning

February 26 2005, 22:41:10 UTC 7 years ago

made this today - thank you - it is wonderful!

[info]thirdjane

February 27 2005, 03:53:56 UTC 7 years ago

You're very welcome! I'm thrilled you enjoyed it!

[info]jbmanning

February 27 2005, 13:33:52 UTC 7 years ago

Hubby says that stuff is the bomb!

[info]luxlis

June 1 2005, 21:38:50 UTC 7 years ago

Just wanted to drop a line and let you know that I finally got around to making this and it is amazing. Thanks for the recipe : )
Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Facebook Twitter More login options
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…